Wednesday, March 27, 2013

Dissonance

I was thinking about my DNA results this morning--more about that another time--and my being 10% Ashkenazi. Several of my friends, when told, said, "Duh!" I love that. As I have written before, more than once in my past I have been grabbed by fellow students to be taken to Hillel meetings. Or Jewish boys have thought for certain I was in the tribe. Well, sort of, in a very remote way. It was strange to be recognized as being Jew-ish without having a clue about it myself.

And then...I get some photographs on my phone, from my husband, who is visiting his dad in Germany. They are reminders of the stash of photographs we can never put up on the wall. EVER. Of course, forget the one of Opa with Goebbels at Hitler Youth Camp. I find them fascinating as historical documents; they're nerve wracking otherwise since I know the sitter.

And the Ahnenpass, the official Nazi-enforced family tree/document to "prove" that there was no Jewish blood in the family.





It's just one of those days of clashing.

I think *I* have identity issues? My kids are going to have quite their own.




Monday, March 11, 2013

The More Things Don't Change

I credit Addie Pray for bringing me into the fold of online adoptees, nearly five years ago. She is another Missouri adoptee, and she has been active in the slow slog towards getting Missouri adoptees their OBCs. As she wrote on her blog about four years ago, "let's face it, Missouri needs a kick in the ass." *sigh*

This year there was a proposed bill that seemed like more of the same of what we already have or have had, what with requiring CIs to go between adoptee and first parents, and notarized "permission slips" and paying whatever costs the CIs come up with in finding our first families--too much room for abuse, and no respect for adult adoptee integrity. I know exactly whom my agency would appoint: the same CI who was abusive to me and my mother before. Why would she be more efficient, except that I could give her telephone numbers and addresses? I cannot imagine she'd be more on the ball, or kinder, or charge less. I have read online that she's told more adoptees than me that their first parents want nothing to do with them. I wonder to myself, "Did she actually find them? Or did she phrase introductions so coldly that things were made impossible?" Hard to tell; I am skeptical and not particularly forgiving.

I know that some people in Missouri have just loved their CIs, and more power to them. That's beside the point, however. I consider the CI system itself infantilizing. Arguing about "good" versus "bad" CIs is details, not substance. Why should any of us be required to pay anyone to do this go-between work for us to the tune of $500+ (that some people cannot afford, btw); why should we have to be treated as potential criminals; why should the state be involved to such a degree in people's business in the first place?

How about a bill that allows adoptees to go to the appropriate courthouse, pay a fee, and get her or his OBC? How about that? Oh, yes, then the CIs would be out of work; I am sure they're lobbying in favor of those "closeted" mothers, and guileless little adoptees, their meal tickets.

Getting one's OBC is about getting a document that everyone else has a right to have for themselves: it's a government-issued document about ourselves. It's not about searching, or not only about searching. I found my family without mine; many people do. OBC access is a matter of integrity, a matter of insisting that the state not sanction secrets. That's why clean bills are so important. Why are some individuals simply more fortunate, more deserving than others? I have lived too long on the margins among the outcasts to agree that it's all right to create more fortunate/less fortunate groups and hope for more change down the road. Wait for what's right.

I refused to write letters for in support of HB 252 this year. I find its terms unacceptable and unconscionable. I include the part related to me below, emphasis mine. And especially fuck permission slips, written for adults. We are not children.


453.515. 1. (1) For all adoptions completed on or prior to August 28, 2013, an adopted person who is at least eighteen years of age, born in this state, and provides proof of identification, or the adopted person's lineal descendants if the adopted person is deceased, may request that the department of social services, the child-placing agency which processed the adoption, or the court personnel make reasonable efforts to notify the birth mother and birth father of the request of the adopted adult or the adopted adult's lineal descendants to request their consent to release a copy of the adopted adult's original birth certificate. If the department of social services does not have sufficient information or resources to locate and notify the birth mother and birth father, the department may refer the adopted person or the adopted person's lineal descendants to, or work in conjunction with, the child-placing agency or the court to notify the birth mother and birth father of the request of the adopted adult or the adopted adult's lineal descendants. The department of social services, the child-placing agency, or the court may charge actual costs to the adopted adult or the adopted adult's lineal descendants for the cost of attempting to notify the birth mother and birth father. All communications under this section are confidential. For purposes of this subsection, "notify" means personal and confidential contact with the birth mother and birth father of the adopted adult, which initial contact shall be made by an employee of the department of social services, the child-placing agency which processed the adoption, court personnel, or some other licensed child-placing agency designated by the department of social services, the child-placing agency, or the court. Nothing in this section shall be construed to permit the disclosure of communications privileged under section 491.060.
            (2) If the birth mother and birth father consent to the release of the original birth certificate, the department of social services, the child-placing agency, or the court personnel shall obtain a copy of a notarized form developed by the state registrar provided by the court and signed by the birth mother and birth father, if known, giving consent to release the original birth certificate and provide it to the adopted person or the adopted person's lineal descendants. The adopted person or the adopted person’s lineal descendants may obtain a copy of the adopted person's original birth certificate in accordance with subsection 5 of section 453.510 upon presenting the notarized consent form to the state registrar.
            (3) If the birth mother or birth father does not consent to the release of a copy of the original birth certificate or cannot be located, such copy shall not be released. The adopted person or the adopted person's lineal descendants if the adopted person is deceased may request that the department of social services, the child-placing agency, or the court personnel contact the birth mother and birth father again not less than three years after the date of his or her original request and not less than three years from the date of any future requests.
            2. Upon the birth mother's and birth father's death, the adopted person or the adopted person's lineal descendants if the adopted person is deceased may obtain a copy of the original birth certificate from the state registrar.
            3. Any time a copy of an original birth certificate is obtained under this section, the state registrar shall issue an uncertified copy of the unaltered, original birth certificate to the adopted person or the adopted person's lineal descendants if the adopted person is deceased. The copy of the birth certificate shall have the following statement printed on it: "For informational purposes only - not to be used for establishing identity."











Tuesday, March 05, 2013

Who Will Pay for Greed?

My union is still in contract "negotiations" with Sutter Health, a Utah based not-for-profit hospital consortium. I hate them. So much.

I am glad to have my union to protect me, but Sutter is doing all it can to bust the union. We have been striking and fighting not for raises, but simply to maintain our contract and *safe* working practices for over 18 months.

My unit, Labor and Delivery, has the most activists in our two hospitals. All of us in L&D but ONE honor the strike. That's over 150 nurses on the line. We are punished routinely for this with not enough staffing when we need it. Last week, for example, night shift had only 14 nurses with a board that called for 24 nurses just to be safe. Our charge RN called the managers to ask for time-and-a-half to call nurses in to work at 3 am. I mean, who in their right mind is going to come in to work when it's slammed, as a favor to the employer? Seriously? Patients were waiting in triage, delivering in the hallway, bleeding. It was unsafe.  The manager: "No. We cannot authorize overtime because the union is voting on a strike next week."

So management has made the decision to jeopardize patient safety because we RNs are entitled to strike  under labor law. It's horrific, and punitive, primarily to patients.

We have had multiple near misses for bad events. What will it take for them to meet with us to talk about patient safety? One death? Two? Three? How many dead babies?

We had invited the Chief Nursing Executives to meet with a union committee focused on patient safety for over a year. No response. A month ago, they finally agreed. They asked as many L&D RNs to come to the committee meeting as possible to talk about what we've witnessed. Many of us did. Then the executives canceled at the 11th hour and sent designees from HR instead, who, by the way, are now called "Business Partners," just to make it clear they're not there for us, but for the corporation. The Business Partners, moreover, had nothing to do with staffing, and nothing to do with L&D. Interesting. They promised to take our messages to management, but after the meeting never returned our e-mail or telephone calls. Interesting. In true punitive form, HR hijacked *our* meeting to tell us that we were "unprofessional" for not treating traveler RNs (the ones who were scabs for our strikes but then hired to help out sometimes when our staffing was low) politely enough. We said that we were polite, but that we didn't need to be friends with them. He rolled his eyes at us. How professional is that?

So no change.

Then yesterday a follow-up meeting was scheduled, and HR was told that they were not invited. It was for the nursing executives *only* to attend with us. HR told us that it was five "Business Partners," plus the nursing executives, or nothing. Our contract states that we cannot deal with HR directly, but that if the nursing executives designate one of them as proxy, that is all right. ONE person, ONE proxy. Not five plus three. There was a standoff outside the door, and HR would not let the executives speak when we invited the executives alone inside. We consequently did not let *any* of them enter our meeting. It was a union meeting, a closed meeting. Clearly, HR wants to police us and the executives so that nothing is promised (i.e., no money is spent). It's sick.

Oh, and one of the "Business Partners" told our Labor Rep that "so many RNs in a room is intimidating." Well, maybe to him. But the nurse managers MANAGE all of us, so it shouldn't be all that intimidating if they're doing their job right and want to listen and make change.

Please, no one tell me to hear Sutter's side. Don't tell me that it's expensive to hire staff. It's morally wrong to have someone die when conditions are known to be less than what the state demands. We are writing up exceptions and letting everyone know. It's not about their feelings v. our feelings. Sometimes, there is a WRONG side. We have a moral obligation to do no wrong, not just take the patients' money (or MediCal).

I don't want patients to suffer, but apparently Sutter thinks $$$ comes first. Which is crazy, given all the overtime they end up paying us, anyway. I am going to file an affadavit and stand before the National Labor Relations Board, if needed, regarding the committee meeting fiasco. It's harrassment and unacceptable.

Sutter is trying to break our resolve to stand together. They won't do it. Stay tuned.


Thursday, February 21, 2013

Creating Meaning

Since my trip to see the Drawing Surrealism exhibition at LACMA, I have been thinking about Apollinaire's calligrammes, which aren't surrealism proper but are so fraught with curious meaning. They have been talked to death; earnest people make calligrammes for their loved ones all the time. They're the poetic equivalent of Monet, really. But still I love Apollinaire's originals.

They're dark and can be quite nasty, despite their outwardly cheery, pretty facades. The political and emotional messages are fabulously pointed.


As in, how can a horse be "all horribly/dreadfully/terribly"? Think about it. Fantastic. Of course, now thinking about it, it's a juxtaposition of the horse, and a description of himself, his signature. I wish I had that kind of deprecating humor and moxie. I might say it, but I wouldn't write it.

And speaking of the French, I recently discovered a group that has revived the old song tradition that I so love. For some reason, blogger won't let me use accents, which is embarrassing, but they're called the "Tetes Raides." They appeal to the nostalgic nerd in me who idealizes the 30's and 40's. I especially like this collaboration with Jeanne Moreau.





Wednesday, February 20, 2013

Competing Memories, Persistent Memories

I went to the ballet last Friday and saw a production of "Nijinsky," John Neumeier's take on what went through Vaslav Nijinsky's head during his last performance in 1919. It touched on the highlights of his dance career, his loves, war. There were moments in which persistent memories abutted competing memories; Nijinsky would be torn away from one lover by remembering another, for example. Or he would remember dancing Le Sacre du Printemps while a passage from La Sylphide would glide through.

It resonated with me. As well as Nijinsky's madness, of course. Always the madness. But is it madness, or is it simply trying to make sense of things that don't made sense, that cannot make sense? When does reverie bleed into trauma, pleasure turn into self-hatred and doubt?

I have been thinking quite a bit about the past, and mourning, and remembering, and revisionism, especially in trying to make sense of a relationship of mine that failed sixteen plus years ago now. I am finally seeing that I was rather doctrinaire, and different things are coming into focus that are helpful.

What does it mean to put someone first, to love them? Does it mean that they have to be with you all the time? That others cannot love and appreciate them, too? I was so very young and scared. I remember, in particular, when I was planning to walk to receive my master's degree. My then-boyfriend was going to be the best man in a college friend's wedding, in Idaho. My graduation weekend conflicted with the wedding, which meant I could not attend the wedding: all my family would be in Berkeley and had to be entertained. My guy really wanted to be in the wedding. I felt horribly betrayed by this preference, although he made it back in time for my actual graduation ceremony. In retrospect, his choice seems like such a petty thing to worry about, but at the time, it felt HUGE, absolutely as though he didn't love me at all. (I was 25 at the time, with not that much else to worry about.) Shouldn't I come *first*? Looking back, I see that I spent so much energy in that relationship being highly anxious about whether he loved me, when now, being secure in who I am, I can see that he really did love me all the time--just perhaps not in the all consuming way I wanted then. It's very sad. I might have been a very annoying girlfriend, I realize. I am sorry now that I was so insecure and lost that I spent New Year's Eve in Provence crying; that I moped in Scotland; that I didn't have it in me to be, to enjoy the moment. Especially because we were so alike in very many ways. But somehow I think that learning to live in the moment is something that had to come with age, at least for me.

I cannot say that our relationship would have survived had I been more secure in myself back then (I was the one who ended it, eventually), but it would have probably made for many fewer nights spent crying and singing to Gloria Gaynor.

The strange thing is that I always think that when I exit someone's life, I am erased. I remember them, but they don't remember me. I am like a ghost. Or they hate me, or some other such extreme thing. Especially because I have been in relationships with people who resolutely cut off contact without a word, and when I try to approach them even decades later--some of the ones I have truly cared about--they are still and silent as a tomb. I figure that either they continue to see me as the crazy fool I once was, or, as a wise friend recently suggested, they are unwilling to go bumping around in the basement of their feelings. Blinders and complacency do have much to say for themselves in terms of self-preservation.

I am therefore pleasantly surprised when people who clearly, truly did once love me are receptive and warm and kind. They are validating me outside my own mind; I mattered to them, as well. That is an amazing feeling.

My recent excursions into the past have thus been fruitful in that I have discovered some compassion for myself. I was so lost, so blind, so insecure. I created disasters in my head that weren't real and then possibly made myself live them, over and over. People do love me, even if it isn't exactly the way I might have imagined or hoped that they would.

That's what I've been missing: faith in myself and in others. Not faith in everyone, but faith in the right people, without willfully misreading the signs. I welcome those memories, competing and persistent, as they help me to learn new things about myself.








Sunday, February 10, 2013

What Is the Starting Point?

I was thinking recently about the notion that adoption exists, that it simply is, and that we must deal with it. That we must find our home within it, as it is, or make pleas for small changes in the name of social justice, and be happy with glacial responses ("Hey! It's progress!). That if we're polite enough and use the subjunctive case with precision, "the powers that be" will grant us a seat at the table, and we can effect change. To be joyful with acknowledgments of small change; to accept everyone's opinion as "only their opinion" as though that isn't dividing and conquering in one fell swoop.

Well, adoption simply hasn't always existed the way it does today. To take adoption in 2013, and say that I must be polite to those suffering from Adopter Savior Syndrome as the starting point (offending them only scares them away!) is granting those in power the parameters of the discussion. I am angry. I don't want to be a house slave. I am well trained enough to be one, but I don't want to be one.

I work every day with people who are more disenfranchised than I am. Who live on the margins of society, and who are denigrated for being there, who are blamed for their "problems." No, American culture is far, far, far from equal for all. Even given the same education, some people are disadvantaged. They don't know that they're entitled to the same funding and concern as upper middle-class students of the dominant culture. I read an article in The Times in December, about three young women of color in Texas who did not manage to make the big step up in class, even given their considerable brains, because they lacked social and institutional supports. Another man I know is a professor at a local community college that used to provide services primarily to minority, low-income populations in the Bay Area. Many of these students lost their financial aid, however, because they didn't know how to ask for help with forms; because they had questions but didn't feel entitled to go to office hours, and so on. One particular student failed a required class called "Career Planning" and thus lost his grants: otherwise he had straight A's. First of all, who among us privileged people ever the hell had to take a class called "Career Planning" in college? What the hell is it, anyway? Why would that even be required for an A.A. degree? [Please don't answer that: it's a rhetorical question.] Second, if he'd felt entitled to more (which he didn't, sadly) he could have gone to the professor, or the dean to argue the decision. That's what all the people who went to college with me did when they were unhappy with anything; then again, their parents were paying $25,000+/year. Entitlement is taught as part of social privilege; it is an invisible cloak for those who have it, and it can be devastating to those who don't have it. Anyway, the local community colleges are now filled to the brim with middle-class white kids who are deferring entrance to four-year schools to save Mom and Dad money. Their parents pay the bills on time, they come to school reliably, etc. Who do you think has been squeezed out by this influx of middle-class kids? Yes! You're right! The very students whom the community college were supposed to be helping in the first place.

Then I was mulling over, again, this idea of the history of adoption, and of culture. I was reading a friend's blog and his thoughts on how the West projects onto Islam its worst fears. It scapegoats Muslims for what it fears most in itself, and within that unadmitted conceit, the notion of "saving" children is even more repugnant. His writing on adoption and the power of language here is particularly powerful, although he is always worth careful attention for his insights.

I suppose I am a socialist at heart, at the very least, maybe even a communist. I am coming out the closet. I do know that I am sick to death of totalitarian regimes, adoption included.






Saturday, January 26, 2013

Representations of Self

I noticed that members of the Open Adoption Roundtable are doing a blog hop around art that they have in their homes. I am neither an open adoption blogger nor a serious artist/collector, but as I was in my kitchen this morning, I thought that I could share some of the works I have hanging in my home and why they represent me (if it's not immediately obvious).

On my long-ago trip to India, my friend Thomenon and I went to the Jama Majid (great mosque) in Old (Mughal) Delhi at 5:30 in the morning. The light was perfect. We wandered around, talked to people, listened to the fountains, and I watched the cats with delight. I took a slide of two men, after asking their permission, as they were talking on a porch (it was going to be for teaching purposes, back in the dark ages). I was surprised how beautifully the image turned out. My husband had the slide restored and made into a picture on canvas, that we mounted in the kitchen. The scene reminds me of my trip, and I imagine the men's friendship. I can remember the coolness of the marble under my bare feet, and the smell of the city. It's intensely personal.


On the other side of the kitchen are two photographs. One is a documentary photograph (copy of an original from the 20's) of a lid of a casket from the tomb of Tutankhamun, from which I taught my kids some rudimentary hieroglyphs, and how to read cartouches (pretty much all I know, to be honest). I love that the form of the lid is a cartouche.


Next to it is a print of a photograph by Charles Sheeler, the American photographer/painter, who did some photography for the Metropolitan Museum in 1943. He took this marvelous shot of some arms from a Neo-Assyrian relief, showing a king, Assurnasirpal II, and his cupbearer. Considering how blocky and schematic much of Neo-Assyrian art can look, I love the articulation of the muscles and the jewelry. Sheeler made such an interesting choice in how he framed this, with the phallic dagger hilt, the snake's head on the cup, and all. It's 100% testosterone. I wrote my A.B. thesis on the Neo-Assyrians and have a very soft place in my heart for the art of these warlords.


Next to my bed I have a framed print of the white hart from the Wilton Diptych, representing Richard II. I see it every morning when I awake. It reminds me of my childhood in England; my lithe staghounds, the Arts and Crafts Movement (which mined such objects for inspiration); Catholicism (it's part of an altarpiece); and peace. I apologize for the not-so-lovely photograph, but the glare on the glass was hard to avoid. (You can see my elder child, currently ill, lying in bed and reading if you look hard enough.) I couldn't get a decent picture because of terrible lighting, but I have a framed print of the scene of Virgin, Child, and Angels from the Diptych over my desk; the blue (surely expensive lapis) of the Virgin's and angels' gowns is calming, and I can always use the blessing of the Madonna.



And my muse, this young woman with a stylus (sometimes identified as Sappho), watches over the living room and my collection of books. I have adored this Roman wall painting from Pompeii for decades; she reminds me of myself. When I first put this up, Dad saw her and said, "Oh, it's YOU!"



Saturday, January 19, 2013

Women's Bodies

I have had some rough cases at work recently, dealing with demises of babies close to term, but not quite. And having to help moms deal with their losses, and their tipping over the edge into despair that was truly psychosis. Extremely sad to watch. I felt powerless to do anything except to sit there and listen.

I am dedicated to helping women and children be healthy and safe. Every day at work, my goal is "Healthy mom, healthy baby."

And then I read horrible stories about women being sent to jail for ridiculous things concerning pregnancy, mostly because of their race and class. I hope you will read this article and think of ways in which we can work together to advocate for women who don't share the same privileges we do. I've copied the first paragraphs below.


Pregnant? That Might Get You Arrested



Abortion continues to be a hot-button issue in the US, as dozens of states have passed measures to limit women's access to the procedure. But even women who want to be pregnant are not free of legal restraints on their bodies, as a new paper in the Journal of Health, Politics, Policy and Law demonstrates. In many instances, women have been arrested, institutionalized, or subjected to unwanted medical interventions due to their pregnancies.
The paper looks at 413 criminal and civil cases from 1973 to 2005 in which women were subject to legal action related to their unborn children. In all the cases, the women were deprived of their own civil liberties by legal authorities claiming to seek protection of the fetus. Many dealt with charges related to drug or alcohol use during pregnancy, refusing to follow doctor's orders, or for miscarriages that were blamed on their actions (even if there was little to no evidence to prove that those actions led to the miscarriage).
In a piece at RH Reality Check, the paper's authors detail some of the examples they found in their search of legal and public records, as well as media accounts. Here are just a few of them they include: 
  • A Louisiana woman was charged with murder and spent approximately a year in jail before her counsel was able to show that what was deemed a murder of a fetus or newborn was actually a miscarriage that resulted from medication given to her by a health care provider.
  • In Texas, a pregnant woman who sometimes smoked marijuana to ease nausea and boost her appetite gave birth to healthy twins. She was arrested for delivery of a controlled substance to a minor.
  • A doctor in Wisconsin had concerns about a woman's plans to have her birth attended by a midwife. As a result, a civil court order of protective custody for the woman's fetus was obtained. The order authorized the sheriff’s department to take the woman into custody, transport her to a hospital, and subject her to involuntary testing and medical treatment.
Fifty-two percent of the women in the cases they found  were African American. Seventy-one percent were likely low income, as they were represented by indigent defense in the legal case. Sixty-nine percent were under the age of 30, and 56 percent were in the South. And, lest you think these are mostly old cases, they found more than 25 in 2005, the last year included in the paper. The authors also said that, while not included in this research, they are aware of at least 250 cases since 2005.


Tuesday, January 08, 2013

Reactive Attachment Disorder, Racism, and Resistance

I have recently felt over, so over being adopted; not that I can erase it from my identity, but that I am too busy just living to focus on anything remotely related to its thorniness or boggy idiocies. I have had nothing meaningful to say about adoption, and I haven't being reading much of interest, either. Novellas, short stories, and criticism are more up my alley at the moment.

I was moved, however, by my friend Daniel's thoughts on Reactive Attachment Disorder as he expressed them over at Transracial Eyes. I encourage you to read his post, if you haven't already.

Here are the first wonderful, challenging paragraphs:


I’d like to touch back on to two discussions we’ve had so far, one on nature vs. nurture as posited by Snow Leopard, and the other one having to do with Russian adoptions, and the idea of a second-best race-based adoption, i.e., one that does not (seemingly) require those adopting from having to mythologize their ability to raise a transracially or transculturally adopted child.
The reason I think this deserves more focus in terms of Russian adoptees is that from the web sites that I’ve seen on so-called Reactive Attachment Disorder (RAD), the majority of the children so diagnosed seem to come from predominantly “white-identified” countries: Russia and Eastern Europe, read: those places deemed as deserving salvation from Soviet-era “Godless Communism”.
Much of the RAD diagnosis is focused not on the adoption itself, but instead on the child as manifesting an “illness” that needs to be corrected via a variety of therapies physical and psychological that I believe would constitute torture if performed on prisoners of war, as defined by the Geneva Convention.
So much of the discussion that needs to be had here seemingly can’t be had, if only because at first glance we are not dealing with a question of “racism”. I would like to challenge this, while also pointing out that the notion of “adoption” is just as culturally specific as the psychological diagnosis of RAD, along with the racism implied.

Saturday, December 01, 2012

Fresh Starts

I saw The Life of Pi today, and even knowing vaguely what the book was about (I don't read an overwhelming about of contemporary literature, and hadn't read this one), I wasn't prepared for the harrowing emotional experience I felt while watching the narrative unfold. I adore Ang Lee as a director, and he didn't disappoint, but the story of a young man and a tiger lost at sea, the young man having lost everything else, was brutal. The angry sea, the shipwreck, the lives taken by the water, the inescapable fear.

I thought certain parts of it, in which the boy takes in the lessons of many different religions and synthesizes something out of them for himself, was interesting. Having a friend who has written academic papers at length on Vishnu and the Churning of the Ocean of Milk, the references to Vishnu on the Cosmic Ocean were familiar, as was Krishna. I have been to religious festivals in India, and seeing the people and the lights and the gods brought back happy memories. I loved it when the young Pi questioned the priest about why God would send his Son to suffer for us, and Pi kept retuning to ask more questions, looking up at the Stations of the Cross in the church in the hills near the tea plantations.

There were layers upon layers of meaning in the film; as A.O. Scott said in a discussion of narrative in film recently, it's both a reminiscence and a fable, "about the nature of storytelling itself." Given the Indian context of the story, I was surprised not to have Buddhism in the religion mix. With all the animals around, I was reminded of the jataka tales, or stories about the previous lives of the Gautama Buddha in which he lived as various animals and performed good works.

I also thought much about aloneness and making hard choices, losing faith (or perhaps gaining it), and not wanting to be alone and obscure: your narrative, oral or otherwise left untold. And now, thinking about it, it is interesting that the Indian man from Pondicherry shared his story as an oral narrative while the white man will be the one to write it down. Hmmm.

As much as I like my solitude, the kind of solitude endured by Pi and Richard Parker was terror inducing. There were moments when I couldn't watch at all, and crouched with my head in my lap. It was more triggering than any film I have seen since I cannot remember.

Worse for me even than Mother and Child.

And yet there are such strands of pleasure and the sublime in it that I can relate to on both visceral and intellectual levels that I cannot stop thinking about it.

The ending made me think of fresh starts and personal narratives and how stories are told are "preferable" by one group or another. There is always something lost in the telling, no matter how you weave your story; it is most important, however, that your story have meaning for you.

And so ends November. I doubt that I shall have the fortitude to blog every day in December, but I shall try not to be overwhelmed by personal lassitude wrought by National Adoption Awareness Month.

ETA: I posted this last evening, at 11:45, but Blogger failed me. So it turns up as a December 1 post. It is a fresh start.

Thursday, November 29, 2012

Recovery

I did a dumb thing last week. I was playing at my kids' school with them and banged my right foot really badly wearing Wellies. I am too embarrassed to tell you what I did exactly, but it was a bad connection between foot and metal. I limped home slowly and seriously thought I'd broken my right big toe. I broke my left big toe when I was 18, and it felt remarkably similar. I knew my injury was my fault, and I felt stupid. But there wasn't much I could do about it at that point (my family was having too much fun laughing at me to beat myself up any further). Broken or fractured or bruised, oh well. Ice the toe, take Advil, and suck it up. I had good range of motion, so I knew it wasn't worth darkening my MD's door.

It hurt. It was swollen. It got worse, then better-ish. But it was hot and red. Never a good sign.

On Sunday, I worked. It wasn't awesome to have to hustle in the hallways, but I survived. Then Monday morning, when I was watching The Walking Dead  and drinking my coffee, I noticed that the swelling wasn't inflammation swelling: it was abscess swelling. Double gross.

I am a nurse. I prepared my sterile field and lanced the grossness. It was gratifyingly full bacterial effluvia. Problem was that there was involvement of the nail and atrophy of the tissue behind the nail. I knew that the nail had to go, just not when or how. I knew it should probably go soon to prevent more bacterial growth. I was keeping the wound clean and irrigating it with normal saline; I checked in with my ED nurse and MD friends. I had a nightmare about gangrene. I spiked a temp of 100 degrees.

Wednesday morning I called my MD and made an appointment; my regular MD wasn't there, but I was able to see the new physician in the practice, who is wonderful. She read my complicated history and said, on coming into the room, "You've really been through a lot!" I appreciated that. Then she looked at my gross toe, immediately wrote me a prescription for Bactrim to take orally, and declined to take my nail off. She said she'd never done it before, and that I should see a podiatrist ASAP.

The receptionist referred me to a podiatrist (outside of UCSF); I drove home and called the podiatrist's office, explaining my problem and the urgency. I was offered an appointment on December 7th! I said that I needed an appointment sooner, and she said it wasn't possible. I asked her what I should do, then. Go to the ER? She said I should take the December 7th appointment. I asked if she'd ever heard of sepsis. I asked her if she could refer me to another office. She did.

Best thing.

The next office was the most fabulous place! They fit me in immediately, were kind and compassionate, and understood what an abscess was. I checked out the DPM on yelp and she is covered in love. I can add to that.

Anyway, I showed up at my appointment today, and she giggled that the primary care MD didn't want to take off the toenail. It took her 15 seconds, after she numbed me up with lidocaine and put on an awesome makeshift tourniquet made from an exam glove. She showed me where the nerves are in the toe, where best to numb them, and described rookie mistakes in numbing. She teased me about how as an RN I could be masochistic enough to lance myself but not take off the nail. I said that I don't have my own private stash of lidocaine, and we laughed. She was nerdy and excellent! It was all surprisingly anticlimactic.

It felt great until the lidocaine wore off. And now it hurts, but I am sure as the nail bed dries I will feel much better. I will wait a year for my nail to grow back, and in the meantime marvel at my nail-less toe. The human body never ceases to fascinate me.

Far from the Tree has arrived, as well, and I am deep into the first chapter. It is written so engagingly that I hope I can put it down and not read all night.


Wednesday, November 28, 2012

Unhappy Families

Anna Karenina famously begins, "All happy families are alike; each unhappy family is unhappy in its own way."

I was reading Julie Myerson's review of Andrew Solomon's Far from the Tree in last Sunday's Times (that book seems inescapable at the moment), and Myerson wrote that Solomon came to an "'anti-Tolstoyan' conclusion that 'the unhappy families who reject their variant children have much in common, while the happy ones who strive to accept them are happy in a multitude of ways.'"

This is fascinating; what makes rejection inevitable and the rejecting families unhappy, while the happy families can accept difference? I have been thinking about my long history of being a variant. I believe that variants do strike fear into the hearts of those who try hard to fit in and not be different from those around them. Those whose goal in life it is not to stick out, not one little bit. Our (variants') being around, and talking about who we are, can be an enormous threat to the balance that some work so hard to achieve and pass off as effortless. But variants aren't figments of people's imaginations; we are real. And running away from us doesn't make us go away, except in a physical sense. As do those who have to live with/around/near us: this is a 700+ page book that talks about the real (emotional/physical/financial) difficulties of living with those with horizontal identity. I get it. We're not easy, either. Perhaps in some cases, relationships are broken and never mended, or are broken and then mended (as in the case of Tiffanie DiDonato I wrote about a few days ago).

In her review in the Times, Myerson indicates that Solomon writes perceptively about the challenges of figuring out who we are: "[Solomon] knows about the humiliations involved in the search for (in his case, sexual) identity. He knows what it is to feel like a freak." And as a fellow freak, apparently he writes without judgment. I thank him for that. It sounds like he is wonderfully empathetic and intelligent and probing, having compiled 40,000 transcript pages from interviews with many families and distilled his findings into this book.

A reviewer on amazon.com said that she got caught up by some great sentences on page 2 of Far from the Tree, which certainly resonate with me, both as an adoptee and as a parent:

"Parenthood abruptly catapults us into a permanent relationship with a stranger, and the more alien the stranger, the stronger the whiff of negativity." 

"From the beginning, we tempt them into imitation of us and long for what may be life's most profound compliment: their choosing to live according to our own system of values. Though many of us take pride in how different we are from our parents, we are endlessly sad at how different our children are from us."

I am incredibly excited to read this book (my copy on order is taking TOO long), and I cannot believe (well, yes I can) that adoption wasn't included as an example of horizontal identity. Perhaps it's an invisible example?


Tuesday, November 27, 2012

Diversity

I am an adoptee, and in that sense I belong to a social minority. I was asked today to think about diversity. My life has been immeasurably enriched by friends who belong to groups very different from mine: genders, social classes, ethnicities, cultures, and so on.

How do we definite diversity?
According to Merriam-Webster:
di•ver•si•ty:
1. the condition of having or being composed of different elements; VARIETY; especially, the inclusion of different types people (as in people of different races or cultures) in a group or organization diversity
in schools>2. an instance of being composed of differing elements or qualities: an instance of being diverse diversity
of opinion>
The first definition is about how a group of people looks, perhaps, or define themselves; their families, abilities, or ethnicities. The second definition isn't necessarily about ideas, but the example they chose is interesting in that it does.

We absolutely have a diversity of opinion in adoptoland, although that diversity not always welcomed or praised. We also have a diversity of adoptees, and of adoptee experiences (and of course, of first parent and adoptive parent experiences, too). Some of us adoptees are older than others; some of us are infant adoptees; some of us are international adoptees; some of us are foster adoptees; some of us are in reunion; some of us are not. Some of us spend hours thinking about what adoption has meant; some of us don't think much about it at all. Some of us have written books about adoption; some of us have written about other topics. Some of us are artists; some of us are comedians; some of us are professional chefs; some of us have moved home to the countries of our births. Some of us are activists; some of us care more about our clothes than about our bloodlines. Some of us are depressed; some of us are unquenchably happy. To quote Kurt Vonnegut, "So it goes."

And all of it is okay.

Today I send out love to all of my adoptee comrades, wherever you are, whoever you are. Pax. We are in this together.

Diversity is what makes us strong. I have learned more--the most, perhaps--from the people living lives most divergent from mine. Those were the people who encouraged me to look hard, and carefully, at myself, to scrutinize my unearned privilege, to look at the unspoken things that I can take for granted. Things that many other people cannot, just by virtue of who they were born, and where they were born, and the why of their births. Inequalities don't come from nowhere.

I know I have posted this beautiful, heartbreaking essay before, by my wonderful friend who has seen me through thick and thin and taught me more about diversity and justice and what my role in changing things needs to be, and why, than anyone else. But I want to honor him today by posting it again.


Monday, November 26, 2012

Small Shelf

I always love getting The Times around the holidays, when it is brimming with suggestions of great books to give as gifts. One book sounds interesting, less for its contents than as an idea. Thessaly La Force has collected a list of 100 famous people's favorite books, asking them to imagine what books (the amount that would populate a small shelf) would best describe them. The book, titled, My Ideal Bookshelf is also sunnily illustrated by Jane Mount. I would be interested in seeing what appears most commonly on the lists (apparently it's not George Eliot), and perhaps there would be some little gem that I would not otherwise have known. I am certain I will thumb through this and have a look.

I was trying to think which books I would choose, and was realizing that rather oddly, I would begin with a stack of things that I read in high school, and that I read quite concentratedly in junior year. My English teacher, Mr. Bayer, and I have similar taste, I suppose. He knew how to choose good books!

Thomas Mann's Death in Venice; Franz Kafka's The Metamorphosis; Euripides' Medea; Anton Chekhov's The Steppe. Good old Macbeth.

And then things I discovered on my own: Virginia Woolf's Mrs. Dalloway and all her short stories; Elizabeth Bowen's short stories; Katherine Mansfield's short stories; Emily Bronte's Wuthering Heights (forget Charlotte and her insufferable Jane Eyre); Jane Austen's Northanger Abbey: Leo Tolstoy's Anna Karenina; Henry James's Portrait of a Lady; Harold Bloom's Stories and Poems for Extremely Intelligent Children of All Ages; John Guy, ed., Wonder of the Age: Master Painters of India, 1100-1900; K. Lange and M. Hirmer, Egypt; C. Baldick, ed. The Oxford Book of Gothic Tales. The Tempest (if not the RSC's William Shakespeare Complete Works); Homer's Odyssey.

My small shelf is full, I believe. I am sure if you asked me tomorrow, there would be a few small differences. but probably nothing major. Wow, am I Eurocentric. And pretty predictable. I really love my classics, morose Germans/Austrians and Russians, and early 20th-century women. But I am a European-American woman obsessed with the past, so perhaps it's not all that surprising that these are the books that describe me.

What would be on your shelf?

Sunday, November 25, 2012

More about Horizontal Identity

After I wrote about horizontal identities week before last (and I still mean to read Andrew Solomon's book, Far from the Tree), I ran across an article about a woman, Tiffanie DiDonato, with dwarfism, that referenced Solomon's book. The article I found was in Allure, but still. It gave pause. DiDonato is strong and admirable as hell. But the fact that her grandmother and her father wanted her mother to give her up for adoption: horrifying! The article (by Judith Newman) isn't available online, but I wanted to quote a paragraph from it below (December 2012, p. 132).

When Tiffanie Lorraine DiDonato was born in Worcester, Massachusetts, to parents of normal stature in 1980, her father, Gerry, was advised by his own mother to give his child up for adoption. He told his wife, Robin, to choose between him and the baby. She chose her baby and left him. Tiffanie's father spent the next six months unable to eat or sleep, and the couple divorced, but six months after that they got back together. Gerry has spent the rest of Tiffanie's life making up for that initial bad decision. (It appears to have worked; he and Tiffanie adore one another.)

Talk about triggering; all's well, I suppose. DiDonato is healthy, married, and has a son of her own. She has taken charge of her life, and is happy in her body, which is more than many of us can say.

More power to Tiffanie DiDonato and her family, and to her mother, who stood strong in the face of what must have been overwhelming pressures to relinquish.




Saturday, November 24, 2012

Personal History

In as much as I love history on the page, and I love history in general, it has developed a new lustre for me through my natural family. I have written before about Dad's family in Norway, and how cool they are, but how that's not my history. And how I love Mom's family in all their Ohio and Minnesota glory, red hair and all. But yet when they sit around with the family tree, it's not my family tree (even though I am penciled in--LOL, and I love people on it).

I have a new respect and love for U.S. history now I feel that I have a part in it. I have been told by various members of my natural family that they don't care about genealogy, and that everything I've told them has been news to them, from our being distant cousins of James McReynolds, the crotchety Supreme Court Justice who gave FDR such a rough time (yes, I am a liberal, so that's my read of it) to our having relatives who fought and died in the Revolutionary and Civil Wars. Not that they don't like learning about it, but they hadn't felt a huge inner drive to do much about it on their own. I was very glad to share the great work that my awesome friend Zack has done for me in the genealogy arena with them--love you, Zack!

All this to say that when I saw Steven Spielberg's new film Lincoln today, all I could think about were some documents that Zack had e-mailed me related to my great-great-great-grandfather Russel/Russell (?) Showers, who was killed fighting for the Union, in the 80th Indiana Volunteer Infantry, in 1864 in the Battle of Resaca, as part of Sherman's March to the Sea.


I was crying throughout the film, not only because the script was amazing and the story is fantastic; and the acting is some of the best I've seen in years; and the topic is pertinent to us today in how far (and how little) we have come in terms of human relations; but because I am incontrovertibly tied to real people who died in that war, a heartbreaking war that split families apart, quite literally. I can name someone from that war whose blood runs in my veins, just like my husband can name his grandfather when talking about WWI. It's part of that experience, as another adoptee said to me once, of becoming "a real girl."

I only wish I were as eloquent as Abraham Lincoln was. I wonder what my great-great-great-great grandfather sounded like, and if he ever had the chance to hear the President speak.






Friday, November 23, 2012

Coping and Forgiveness

I was thinking about forgiveness along with thanks yesterday, and talking it over with friends at the dinner I attended. I was talking about being adopted, and before long, one of the guests at the other end of the table piped in with "You were chosen! How lucky you are. Not many of us can say this. We get saddled with the family we're born into, but your parents picked you, just you, out of a roomful of babies and that love is perfect."

Which is, of course, bunk. I wasn't chosen. I was matched with my parents, probably because they were older and had good health insurance. That's what Dad says, anyway. And as I said before, they did have a right to refuse me, but given they'd been wanting and waiting, it was highly unlikely they'd have done so. My dad particularly wanted a girl, and there I was: a female infant, 10 weeks old. If it hadn't been me, it would have been the next available baby. I hold no illusions.

I really like the friend of the host who came out with the social fairytale about my story. She meant well, to be certain. But in telling it, she took over my story and made some pretty huge assumptions. Because, you know, that's what the world is like: it is easier to handle us if we all follow the "chosen baby" story; people can, as I have said before, project all kinds of their own hopes and dreams and wishes onto us. We're receptacles in an odd way, for the way people want the world to be.

I forgive her. I also didn't bother to correct her or to say anything else. I just shut up and asked her about her trip to see Obama's first inauguration, which was quite a journey, apparently. There's nothing quite as safe as deflection (except maybe not talking about oneself at all).

I read a fascinating, heartbreaking blog post at neverforgottenisfound about one adult international adoptee's attempts to come to terms abandonment within the contexts of Korean culture and familial expectations. It is complicated, so complicated. In her place, I don't know that I'd be able to forgive. Perhaps.

I have also been thinking about whether I am too rigid and unforgiving. I know I used to be, but at the same time, one can only forgive the same mistake from the same person so many times before wondering if what they're doing is intentional and not a mistake, if there's an underlying message about how they feel about one that they're trying to share in an indirect way. I know that life is messy, people change, circumstances call for elasticity. I can ask for change, and if it doesn't come, I learn from that lack of change (while being honest with myself about what I am asking of the other person). I can also forgive trespasses while not exactly wanting to put myself in the firing line again, knowing that other people's behavior patterns are not going to change. That means changing my expectations about relationships, and that's okay, as well.

I tend to want to be direct when I am invested in a relationship, and to speak directly about what is upsetting me, or what I hope can change. I run into huge problems when dealing with people who greatly dislike talking directly about feelings or problems. It's not easy, for sure; I often feel guilty about asking for what I need. But I am trying hard to change that.

I definitely have an easier time forgiving others than forgiving myself; as I have blogged about before, I am highly skilled in self-flagellation and wear guilt like fine jewelry. I am a Catholic in my soul, I know it. But I also try to deal with the oppressive weight of my guilt by being realistic, not pretending that what I did never happened. And I also try my best not to hurt that person in the same way again, especially when I love and respect that person. "Sorry" is an underused word, IMO, but it has to come tempered with desire for change. It can be an incredibly empty word, too.

How do you cope with forgiveness?








Thursday, November 22, 2012

Thanksgiving

Happy Thanksgiving to all my fellow Americans!

Don't Let that Horse


Don't let that horse
                            eat that violin

  cried Chagall's mother

                                     But he
                  kept right on
                                     painting

And became famous

And kept on painting
                                 The Horse With Violin In Mouth
And when he finally finished it
he jumped up upon the horse
                                             and rode away
           waving the violin

And then with a low bow gave it 
to the first naked nude he ran across

And there were no strings 
                                        attached

--Lawrence Ferlinghetti

Wednesday, November 21, 2012

Strengths

I am the "art docent" or parent art teacher for my sons' classes. The district cut funding for art teachers years ago and expect the parents to pick up the slack and teach art. Despite myself (I function much better with adults than with children, usually), I enjoy the teaching and have found ways to present material in a way that is accessible and even perhaps interesting to the kids. When they see me on campus, they'll run over and say, "Hey! Tobey's/Callum's mom! I had so much fun in art and have been doing painting on my own, thinking about the Fauves/Picasso/Baroque portraits/Rothko/Malevich!" Whatever lesson it was. I am glad to introduce them to art history and to affirm their art-making. Some day, if they ever choose to go to a museum, maybe they'll have a vague memory of what I taught them, or they'll seek out what they like. At least they have some vocabulary for talking about art.

I did a project with Tobey's first grade class last week, focused on early 20th century art and abstraction as a mode of artistic thinking vs. representational art. The students were excited and full of questions. I told them that I wanted them to paint me something abstract, using gouache. Although they were hesitant at first, they quickly became absorbed into the task I had set them. The end products were gorgeous! One of the other moms is a designer for the North Face; she took the paintings to work to mount them. She said the other designers were incredibly excited by what the children had done and asked permission to Xerox some of the children's work for inspiration. Then the other two first grade teachers came to me and asked me to lead the same session in their classrooms, guiding their parent art docents. It felt good to be of use and to put my art history training to work. Especially when I sometimes dread sitting in front of a classroom of six- and seven-year-olds.

I love sitting quietly my art books, losing myself in good reproductions (even better to be in a museum, but I don't often have the time I'd like for that). I have been hatching a plan to go to the Getty Villa to see the two-thousand year old monumental sculpture of a lion attacking a horse. Probably Hellenistic, taken to Rome as part of spolia during the Empire.




The theme of the lion attacking a horse/deer is older still than the Hellenistic period, and common in the Near East (Mesopotamia, etc.) from the third millenium BCE. There was much borrowing of ideas, cross-pollination, in the ancient Mediterranean; this process of borrowing, or seeing strands of imagination across cultures and periods continues to this day, and perhaps is even more intense, in this period of globalization. (The lion attacking a horse/deer  can also be seen as a strand picked up at times in Islamic art, unsurprisingly).

The sculpture on view at the Getty Villa was restored (to Renaissance taste) by a student of Michelangelo, who gave it the horse's head and both animals' limbs and tails. So as we see it, it is a complex work of art having different layers of artistic contribution. And it also influenced other artists, including painters such as George Stubbs, who painted the subject several times.


Stubb's version of 1770 seems to be more about the horse's pain and death, perhaps, than the triumph of an imperial/royal lion. The horse, in white, is boxed into a corner, shown on what appears to be a ledge. The portentous clouds and darkness and apparent lack of means of escape foreground the fear of the attack. We don't see the lion much at all, but the scream of the horse and the taut muscles and sense of the prey's fight for life, instead. The browns of the lion tend to blend into the background, although the effect appears more stark in reproduction.

This painting, in most art history circles, (besides being considered marginal and British) is labeled as hackneyed. Overwrought. Too emotional. It's the painting on the cover of my thick copy of English Romantic Verse. Too much Shelley in it, maybe?

And yet when I look at the painting as owing something to a long history of a theme, I see something more. I find it eerie and disconcerting, yes. But what about its DNA in relation to the history of art? So many people I trained with at Berkeley wouldn't know the monumental piece from the Capitoline if it bit them in the metaphorical ass. "I don't need to know antiquity," they'd sneer. "I'm studying Picasso." Lame.

Since childhood, I have found more of a home in ideas than people (unless you count portraits, as I have mentioned before, and a handful of other oddballs, like me). I love thinking about esoteric, weird things. It's just who I am. Why did I memorize the Egyptian dynasties when I was eight years old? Why did I specialize in Near Eastern art as an undergraduate? When my parents took me to the Louvre when I was 10, all I wanted to do was haunt the Egyptian and Near Eastern galleries. I told them to go see the Mona Lisa and all the modern stuff without me. I was busy.

I don't know where my fascination for antiquity and art comes from. It's not anyone's but my own, as far as I can tell. But who knows? I may be a throwback, or perhaps I am just "special". LOL

I share my interest in medicine with my brother, the physician. That was affirming to discover. He is intelligent and driven and publishes his research, important research, all the time. He mentors his residents. I admire him for his commitment to his field.

I wonder sometimes what I would have done or been had I followed my desire to be physician. What kind of physician would I have been? If I had chosen that path at 18, I would (likely) have missed out on my world travels and my chance to immerse myself in nothing but books for the 10 years of graduate school. Some of my happiest hours were researching until the British Museum and the National Art Library closed and I was kicked out. I honestly hated handing back rare books and letters and going home to my flat. I was holding a letter of Oscar Wilde's in my hands!

Until about five years ago, I would denigrate myself for being different: for living off the beaten track of my community. As I have written before, parts of my adolescence were torture because I internalized the messages that people around me would share about my being "odd." These were the same people who would argue about whether I had lived in "London" or in "England." And I let them put me down? Unbelievable. It was sad that it took me so long to say to myself, "Why do you care what these people think?" How sad that I was living my life to please people who didn't give me a second thought, except to be jerks. I believe my my self-hatred/self-doubt was part of my being adopted. People-pleasing sucks, but it was what I thought I had to do at the expense of myself (although it's truly impossible to please others all the time: the goalposts are always moving).

Everyone has strengths, and those are to be lauded and loved. As a people-pleaser, I developed mad skills of talking to people about themselves and what they are interested in and love. Who doesn't enjoy an enthusiastic audience when talking about themselves? Easiest conversations ever; I can blend into the background and smile broadly and be known as the "nicest person." I do notice, however, that it's harder to find people to cross the road to talk to me; more recently I believe it's because I have boundaries now and don't put up with certain things. I can think of a couple of examples from nursing school when apparently I terrorized people who overstepped their boundaries with me. Better than being a doormat, I say.

Cynicism aside, I celebrate difference in people; we all have things to learn from each other, which I do on a daily basis, especially at work. And interestingly enough, some of my patients who have the most challenging lives--and the fewest resources--have the most compassion and are the kindest people imaginable.

A good life, in my opinion, is all about having respect for one another, which can be a very hard thing to do. And in the meantime, I will be thinking of the lion and horse, and wondering which one I am feeling like today.






Tuesday, November 20, 2012

Caring, Compassion, Community, Courage

I was on the strike line today. We still do not have a contract. Management claims that we are unwilling to negotiate, which isn't true. They want us to accept an insulting "last, best, and final offer" from their side, which is the act of dictatorship, not negotiation. At other hospitals, Sutter has taken to implementing the changes they want, circumventing the rules of the National Labor Relations Board. Sutter thinks it is above the law.

I am proud to stand with my fellow nurses, who asked that we think of our being together in the union as an act of "caring, compassion, community, and courage." I strike because I care about safe care for my patients. The changes that Sutter wants makes safe care a crap shoot. I have worked with unsafe staffing, and it's scary. Sutter needs to value nurses, not demean them.

An RN working at one of our facilities, fearing reprisal, wrote an anonymous letter and sent it to the local media. I am sharing it below. Her message is important. Think about the work that RNs do, and support us, if you are able!


Dear Readers,

It is with great sadness that I read articles in our local newspapers, disparaging nurses, our work as nurses, our profession and our work colleagues. It is on those days that I wish you could walk a day in my shoes.

Because when I walk into the Sutter Intensive Care Unit where I work, I do so with the strength, purpose, and character to do the very best job I can to take care of my patients. And my patients are the sickest of the sick, coming to the hospital with an extensive list of illnesses and medical conditions, in a medical crisis.

On my shift I most often take care of two patients on life support who have machines breathing for them. And because they cannot do anything for themselves, I clean the runny snotty secretions from their nose, mouth and throat. I wash and bathe their sweaty, soiled bodies, and when they have a loose bowel movement on themselves, I clean their bottom and replace their hospital gowns and bed linen. I feed them their nutrition, and when their doctor visits, I ensure they get the treatment, medications, and therapies that will help them make progress and improve so that they can get better and rejoin their families at home.

And when a patient’s heart stops, I am part of the team of nurses that works tirelessly to save a life, or when blood pressure falls dangerously low, I work to get the medications and treatments to pump blood to their vital organs. If a patient stops breathing, the team is there to ensure that they the life support ventilation they need immediately. And when the time comes for my patient to leave this world, and their family members are too scared to be with them, or cannot be there, I am there to hold my patient's hand, to comfort them and their families with the kindness and words they need at a time when they need it most.

My job is not glamorous, but every day I treat every one of my patients as if they were my mom or dad or husband or child because every one of my patients deserves the very best treatment we can give them, often times on holidays when I dearly wish both they and I could be at home with our families.

At my job I am often yelled at by overworked doctors or by tired family members who are stressed out because their family member is so ill, or because they feel scared or guilty that they couldn't do things differently. I am often screamed at because I cannot come to the phone to answer it fast enough when I am taking great care of my patients and our management has cut our secretarial staff. I am yelled at because I have to wait longer and call more often to get medications from our pharmacy because management has cut our pharmacy staff. I have to make do with fewer wash cloths and towels because we don't have resources. I have to do without my lunch breaks and chart instead because our staffing has been cut. We have nobody to take care of our patients if we step away to get lunch, and we are not allowed to file overtime. I can't take or make calls to my family or doctor's office, and I'm lucky if I get a bathroom break before I am desperate.  And when our nurses talk to our managers about our safety concerns about short staffing, it is important that you know our concerns fall on deaf ears.

And so I wonder how you as a reader and member of the community wants to take care of the person who saves your life or your loved one's life: that nurse who is there for you when you need comfort or care the most. Would you want us to go without healthcare insurance, sick time or lunch breaks? Would you want us to have so many patients that we cannot do our jobs safely? Would you be upset if we did not have the support and supplies to allow us to take the best care of your loved one? And if we injure ourselves on the job moving a patient or contract some illness from our patients, would you want us to come to work anyway and have it interfere with how we care for you?

Should we be compensated like our executives Pat Fry, CEO, $4,788,548, Martin Brotman, Sutter West Bay, $4,287.671, Sara Krevans, Sutter Sacramento Sierra Region, $2.094,933 and Ed Berdick, Sutter East Bay Hospitals, $2,015,930? We are asking for the same wages we make now, not a raise. The very same contract, without cuts. 

Newspaper journalists and Sutter Health report to you that we make exorbitant salaries and have "Cadillac health plans."  I think it is important that your hear from the nurses that take care of you in your community if you are very Ill. I will not make a six-figure salary working a full-time job this year, and my colleague, who just retired after 35 years of service to her community as a Registered Nurse, will make less than $12,000 dollars per year in retirement--not the $84,000 dollars/year reported by Sutter Health. I will retire with NO HEALTH BENEFITS, and if I fall injured on the job as many of my colleagues have, it will be "tough luck" for me from Sutter Health. 

If Sutter implements the changes they propose, your nursing staff will have to come to work to take care of you if they are sick. You will receive less time from your nurses when you are in the hospital, and your nurses will no longer be able to advocate for your care. Your nurse will be placed in unsafe working conditions, and your safety may be compromised. I am surprised that it raised no flags or concerns with our community that a hospital representative and MD would describe a Sutter Health nurse's health insurance plan a "Cadillac health plan" and wants to compromise your health care. When you are priced out of your healthcare, know that your nurses were fighting for you.

In closing I ask you to ask questions of your nurses; find out why they are fighting as they strike for you, their community, and for themselves. When Sutter Health tells you we are asking for too much, know that we are not asking for anything new, and we are out on the line to help maintain the quality of health care for everyone in our community. Please support us as we do. 
 
Sincerely
Registered Nurse, ICU at a Sutter Health Hospital
Posted anonymously, due to fear of being reprimanded by my employer